The Jewish Outreach Institute


 

Feedback

Post Message - Users Profile - Lost Password - Help - Disclaimer - Search - Archives - Active Discussions
The JOI Bulletin Board
...for questions, comments and just chatting about interfaith issues
There are 18615 registered users, have you registered yet?

Home / Interfaith Issues / Family
Reply To This Discussion - Start New Discussion

 

Discussion Topic
 my mother-in-law's anguish
  Family (Started by Linda)
 
Poll Available For This Discussion
 Should I give up? Vote / View Results
 

Discussion Posts
Linda[ Profile - Edit Post1:36 am on 10.26.2004
I just feel awful for my mother-in-law. She was a WWII refugee. The poor gal lost aunts and uncles...possibly her dad, but she and her mother don't talk about it. She decided to have four children to help replace the numbers.

Then, along comes me. I observe holidays with the family, being her adorable son's girlfriend. I asked him if I needed to convert. It's a little awkward for me because I am not a religious person. I see religion as kindness in an unkind world, not as THE TRUTH. He said that I needn't concern myself with official conversion.

Then, we got married. The wedding was a disaster. His mother kept crying and throwing drinks. She rearranged the seating. She kept asking people, "doesn't the bride look awful?" His family trashed our house on our honeymoon.

Since then, she has told my husband that he cannot have children with me. Worse yet, he stopped sleeping with me and forbade me to talk to her about her reluctance to accept me.

I know that it must have been a shock to her, seeing my german-american relatives at the wedding. I know the fact that we've been in the states for the last 150 years doesn't unrattle her nerves. After all, war is the worst thing that people can do, and to be a vulnerable child in the middle of it must be terrifying. So I know that I can't approach this from a logical point of view.

I just know that I can't have my future children hearing their grandmother calling their mother a schicksa. She and her mom use it with an inflection that suggests the nastier translation of the word. I have spoken to his sister about conversion and the fact that my mother's mother's mother's mother's mother was Jewish. She claims that is rubs off if it gets too diluted and that even if I converted, I'd still be a fake.

My husband feels that his family will abandon him if he stays with me. I have to think that he has issues as a replacement child. He refuses to discuss it. I feel like he has chosen his mother over me. He is talking divorce. I'm like the left-over wedding cake that nobody wants.

It's not like I won't convert, their issue is with my ancestry. I'd really like to help them heal, but I don't know how. It's like they are using/abusing religion as an excuse for racism. I don't blame judiasm, I blame war.

I am quite depressed because we were previously very happy. How can I help this poor woman and save my marriage? Is this just hopeless?
 

ip: 69.3.200.11

administrator[ Profile - Edit Post6:31 pm on 10.26.2004
Would that your mother-in-law only realized how sensitive and caring a daughter-in-law she has! And in case no one has said so, welcome to the Jewish community. Thank you for joining your journey with that of the Jewish people.

It seems to me that there are several issues emerging: your relationship with your mother-in-law, your husband's relationship with his mother, and your relationship with your husband. Given the nature of the issues, these represent the threads in a complicated tapestry.

If you learn only one thing from casting your lot with the Jewish people--and that is the Jewish people never gives us hope. However, miracles dont happen on their own. We have to work to make them happen.

There are many questions that I would like to ask so that I might understand better and help more. We can e mail privately or we can talk on the phone. I will also be happy to speak to your husband or mother-in-law. Feel free to contact me at JOI 212 760- 1440 or KOlitzky@JOI.org.

I am here to help.
Rabbi Kerry Olitzky
Jewish Outreach Institute
 

ip: 70.19.99.138

Linda[ Profile - Edit Post12:07 am on 11.9.2004
Thank you, Rabbi, for your kind offer. It seems that it is not going to work out as my husband has filed for divorce. I just don't understand why he married me if he loves me so little.
 

ip: 68.167.228.234

End of posts - Reply To This Discussion - Start New Discussion - Admin / Moderator Options
Home / Family
It is 8:39 am on 6.19.2013 - Your last visit was 8:39 am on 6.19.2013

Powered by BigTalker BB v3.614

Jump to: