Where to Pray for Free on the High Holidays

The High Holidays start this upcoming Monday, and again the issue of Jewish institutions charging members and non-members for tickets has come to light. The practice, also known as “pay-to-pray,” is the subject of quite a debate within the Jewish community. We have written before about the growing trend of institutions offering free or low cost tickets, but with a crumbling economy and high gas prices, it seems particularly relevant this year.

Fortunately, the New York Jewish Week has published a comprehensive listing of various shuls in the area that offer free High Holiday services. In an article titled “You Don’t Need a Ticket to Talk to God,” the paper highlights the people behind many of the free services around town. Whether it’s an Orthodox denomination or Reform, everyone hosting a free service appears to have the same motivation: engagement. They believe that by lowering the cost barrier, they will attract more unaffiliated members of the community who are uncomfortable with the “pay-to-pray” model.

Rabbi Judith Hauptman, who runs free High Holiday services through her group Ohel Ayalah, said: “Precisely at the moment when young people want to be with us, on the High Holidays, that’s when the synagogues shut them out.” Similarly, Rabbi Jill Hausman said that reaching the unaffiliated doesn’t start with asking for money. “I want people to attend with a free heart and be welcome,” she said. “I want people to know I’m here for them.”

This is not just a New York phenomenon, though. For years Chabad has offered free High Holiday services worldwide, easily found through an online directory. Their efforts have been rewarded with greater attendance and recognition. We applaud them for opening their doors to everyone on these days, which is a model we would like to see taken by more institutions in the North American Jewish community. The High Holidays are a great opportunity to welcome people in and establish connections with people and families who may not have a Jewish home. Let’s start this year right by opening our doors to all those interested in affiliating with the Jewish people.

We urge you to contact your local Jewish federations to find out if there are any free High Holiday services being offered in your area, or if any congregations offer reduced cost tickets for non-members. No one should be shut out on these holidays.

Click through to read the Jewish Week’s list of free services in New York.

The Actors’ Temple
339 West 47th Street, New York City
Rosh Hashana: Second evening services, Sept. 30, 7:30 pm

Ohel Ayala Manhattan
Great Hall of the First Presbyterian Church
Fifth Avenue at West. 12th Street.
First day of Rosh Hashanah: Sept. 30, 9 am
Kol Nidre (Yom Kippur): Oct. 8, 6:15 pm and 8:15 pm
Neilah Service and Break Fast: Oct. 9, 5:45 pm

Ohel Ayala Brooklyn
Brooklyn Lyceum, 227 Fourth Ave. (Park Slope).
First day of Rosh Hashanah: Sept. 30, 9 am
Kol Nidre (Yom Kippur): Oct. 8, 6:15 pm and 8:15 pm
Neilah Service and Break Fast: Oct. 9, 5:45 pm

The Flame at Young Israel of New Rochelle
1149 North Ave. – (949) 481-7584
Rosh Hashanah: Sept. 29 and 30, 9:30 am
Yom Kippur: Oct. 9, 9:30 am
Kol Nidre and Neilah TBA

Kol HaNeshamah
The Stephen Gaynor School
148 W. 90th St. btwn Columbus and Amsterdam
(646) 678-2084,
Rosh Hashanah: Sept. 30, 8:30 am, Oct. 1, 8:30 am
Child Care and Children’s Services TBA
Tashlich: Sept. 30, TBA, 91 St. and Riverside Drive Promenade.
Kol Nidre: Oct. 8, 6 pm
Yom Kippur: Oct. 9, 9 am (Break Fast at end of services)

Congregation Beth Simchat Torah
(212) 929-9498,
Rosh Hashanah at Town Hall – 123 W. 43 St.
Sept. 29, 6:30 pm (accessible to the deaf)
Sept. 30, 9 am. Tashlich after services, and 7:30 pm
Oct. 1, 9 am
Yom Kippur at the Jacob Javits Center
Entrance at 36th Street and 11th Ave.
Kol Nidre: Oct. 8, 6 pm
Yom Kippur: Oct. 9, 9am, Yizkor after 10:45 am
Mincah/Neilah: 5 pm, shofar after 7:15 pm

Wall Street Synagogue
47 Beekman St. – (212) 227-7800, ext. 11
Rosh Hashanah: Sept. 30, 10 am; Oct. 1, 10 am, 5:30 pm. Tashlich at South Street Seaport, Pier 16
Yom Kippur: Kol Nidre, Oct. 8, 6:20 pm
Oct. 9, 10 am, 12:15 pm Yizkor, 5:45 pm Neilah

East Side Synagogue
At All Souls Church, 1157 Lexington Ave. – (212) 209-6801
Rosh Hashanah: Sept. 30, 10:45 am
Yom Kippur: Kol Nidre, Oct. 8, 8:45 pm
Oct. 9, 10:45 am – morning service
2:15 pm: Speakers service
4:15 pm: Afternoon service
4:45 pm: Yizkor service
6:15 pm: Neilah service


  1. I am wondering if there are any live or pre-recorded online Rosh Hashanah / Yom Kippur services that can be viewed or logged into. I am a Jew working in Antarctica and celebrating the HHDs with fellow Jews will be impossible unless there is some online method. I wonder if you or any of your readers have an idea on this.

    Comment by Don Shuwarger — September 24, 2008 @ 11:43 pm

  2. There are a couple of places to view High Holiday services online. One is through the Jewish TV Network at Another option is Temple Emanu-el in Birmingham, AL. They webcast all of their services. Go to to find out more.
    Shana Tovah!

    Comment by Levi Fishman — September 29, 2008 @ 9:25 am

  3. For Don Shuwanger there is a wonderful reform service at Temple Beth El, Hollywood FL. The rabbi and cantor are wonderful. Beautiful services. Wish I saw this sight sooner for Rosh Hashanah to tell you about it. But definitely check out Kol Nidre to get an idea. L’Shana Tova

    Comment by Joan Rice — October 6, 2011 @ 6:56 pm

  4. There’s free New Year’s High holiday services at Brooklyn Jewish Xperience with explanatory services for Rosh Hashanah. RSVP to be sure there are adequate seats available: Brooklyn Jewish Xperience is also having a gourmet High Holiday Dinner for young Jewish professionals (18-34)on September 5th. There’s a small fee for the festive 4 course dinner but the High Holiday services are totally free!

    Comment by Matt — August 21, 2013 @ 9:21 pm

Leave a comment



Click Here!